Friday, June 13, 2025
HomeNewsWoman gets life for axe murder of boyfriend

Woman gets life for axe murder of boyfriend

Published on

A Toronto  jury has found a woman guilty of first degree murder for counselling her female lover to kill her then-boyfriend.

Nicola Puddicombe, 36, was found guilty Thursday night and has been sentenced to life in prison for the murder of her boyfriend, Dennis Hoy.

The murder revolved around a love triangle gone sour; the Crown maintained that Puddicombe and her former lover, Ashleigh Pechaluk, allegedly formed a plan to kill Hoy.

Superior Court Justice Mary Lou Benotto charged the jury Tuesday afternoon; they finally came back with their verdict Thursday evening.

Both the Crown and defence assert that it was Pechaluk, not Puddicombe, who inflicted the fatal wounds on Hoy, but Justice Benotto reminded the jury that a person need not to have wielded the murder weapon to be guilty of murder.

Justice Benotto said that for Puddicombe to be found  guilty of murder in the first degree, the Crown must have proved beyond reasonable doubt that Puddicombe meant to have Pechaluk kill Hoy.

After days of deliberation the  jury found Puddicombe guilty,  accepting the Crown’s contention that she aided, abetted and counselled Pechaluk to kill Hoy.

Following the verdict, Justice Benotto sentenced Puddicombe to life in prison with no chance of parole for 25 years.

Dennis Hoy died from six blows to the head with an axe on Oct. 26, 2006.

According to Puddicombe’s statement to police on the night of the murder, she said someone was after Hoy and had slashed his tires.

She told them that he was into “illegal stuff” and had been associating with the Hells Angels.

Crown counsel Tom Lissaman argued her diversion was evidence Puddicombe promoted a plan to mislead police and blame the murder on an unknown intruder.

Ashleigh Pechaluk was tried and acquitted of Hoy’s murder in June of this year. She was the Crown’s main witness in Puddicombe’s trial.

Learn about Centennial College's School of Communications, Media, Arts and Design

Latest articles

RBC Canadian Open fans an advantage to country’s golfers

CALEDON, Ont - Waves upon waves of Canadian fans have come through the gates...

Hughes surges to contention as RBC Open heads to final round

CALEDON, Ont. – Mackenzie Hughes wrapped up Saturday’s third round of the RBC Canadian...

Matthew Anderson soars to new heights on home soil

CALEDON, Ont. - After only his third event, Mississauga native Matthew Anderson made his...

Golf thrives as storm passes at 2025 Canadian Open

CALEDON, ONT. - Following a challenging opening round, the second day of the 2025...

More like this

New theatre project shares real-life stories of former youth from care

A script reading held May 8 at the Young People's Theatre in Toronto was part of an event for the project that celebrated the "little wins" in the lives of young people in and from care, ahead of Children and Youth in Care Day on May 14.

Toronto Public Library’s Photoshop challenge celebrates ‘Buy Canadian’ movement

The Toronto Public Library (TPL), has resurrected the spirit of those wartime posters with a modern twist: They're hosting a challenge for participants to remix historical WWI and WWII posters to reflect the current landscape in Canada.
02:00:04

Canada’s federal party leaders: What are their plans and priorities?

The nation’s political leaders are ready for an election day that will shape Canada's future